# coconutBattery or System Settings: Which Battery Number Should You Trust on a MacBook?

> coconutBattery and macOS can show different battery percentages. What each one reads, which to use for a service decision, and what coconutBattery Plus adds.

Published: 2026-11-17

Trust System Settings for the decision that matters, whether the battery needs service, and use coconutBattery for the detail it lays out in one window, such as capacity in mAh, design capacity, temperature, a saved history and iPhone or iPad batteries. Apple says third-party apps that report battery health "might not be accurate" and that it is best to rely on the information macOS reports, so a percentage from coconutBattery that differs by a few points from **Maximum Capacity** is a reason to compare the definitions, not to doubt your Mac.

## What each one shows

| | System Settings | coconutBattery | Terminal |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Where | **System Settings › Battery**, info button next to **Battery Health** | The app, tabs **This Mac**, **History**, **iPhone/iPad** | `system_profiler`, `ioreg` |
| Capacity | **Maximum Capacity** as a percentage | **Battery Health** as a percentage, plus **Full Charge Capacity** and **Design Capacity** in mAh | The same percentage, or raw mAh keys |
| Service verdict | **Condition**: **Normal** or **Service Recommended** | Not listed on its site | `Condition` line |
| Cycles | In **System Information** under **Hardware › Power** | **Charge Cycles** | `CycleCount` |

The labels in the coconutBattery column come from the screenshots on [its site](https://www.coconut-flavour.com/coconutbattery/), which also list **Battery Temperature**, **Battery Charge**, **Manufacture Date**, **Discharging with** and **Low Power Mode**, and show an iPhone and iPad tab. The site notes that the manufacture date cannot be read on devices with a randomized serial number format. Apple's own wording for the macOS number, in the Battery Health panel, is "a measure of battery capacity relative to when it was new", and for the service verdict, in [Apple's support article](https://support.apple.com/108376), that **Service Recommended** means the battery holds less charge than when new or is not functioning normally.

## Why the numbers can differ

Check these, in this order, before concluding that one of them is wrong:

1. **They are not the same quantity.** macOS publishes one **Maximum Capacity** percentage. coconutBattery shows a **Battery Health** percentage and two raw capacities. In the site's own Mac screenshot, 5,955 mAh against a 6,249 mAh design capacity is shown as 95%, which matches that ratio.
2. **Apple's percentage is not a plain division.** On one MacBook, with macOS 27.2 on November 14, 2026, `system_profiler` reported **Maximum Capacity** 100% with a **Cycle Count** of 73. The raw `ioreg` values on the same Mac were `AppleRawMaxCapacity` 8238, `NominalChargeCapacity` 8482 and `DesignCapacity` 8579 mAh, which divide to 96.0% and 98.9%. A tool that divides raw capacity by design capacity can therefore land a few points away from Apple's figure on the same battery. I did not find a formula for **Maximum Capacity** in Apple's pages, and the Battery Health text in macOS also says "As your battery ages, maximum capacity is reduced to extend battery lifespan".
3. **A key named `MaxCapacity` is not health.** On the same Mac `MaxCapacity` was 100 beside `CurrentCapacity` 80 at an 80% charge, so it is the scale of the charge percentage and not a health figure.
4. **The condition word differs between outputs.** On that Mac, the `system_profiler` text said **Normal**, while its JSON said `Good`.

## Read the same numbers in Terminal

These are read-only and change nothing:

```bash
system_profiler SPPowerDataType -json | grep -E 'cycle_count|battery_health'
ioreg -rn AppleSmartBattery | grep -E '"(CycleCount|DesignCapacity|NominalChargeCapacity|AppleRawMaxCapacity|MaxCapacity|CurrentCapacity)"'
```

The first prints the cycle count, the condition and the **Maximum Capacity** that macOS publishes. The second prints the raw keys, including a `BatteryData` line that holds the mAh values. Keys vary by Mac and macOS version, so treat `ioreg` as diagnostic output. For service decisions and for the exact menu paths, [how to check MacBook battery health](https://mole.fit/blog/how-to-check-macbook-battery-health) already covers the checks, the cycle limits and what to do for each result, so this page does not repeat them.

## What coconutBattery Plus adds

The [site's comparison table](https://www.coconut-flavour.com/coconutbattery/) (read on November 14, 2026, version 4.4, requires macOS 12 Monterey or later) lists these rows:

| Feature | coconutBattery | coconutBattery Plus |
| --- | --- | --- |
| iPhone/iPad Battery Diagnostic | Yes | Yes |
| Mac Battery Diagnostic | Yes | Yes |
| Save Battery Health Info | Yes | Yes |
| Mac Battery Details in Menu Bar | Yes | Yes |
| iPhone/iPad Battery Details in Menu Bar | No | Yes |
| WiFi Support (read an iPhone or iPad without USB) | No | Yes |
| Battery Lifetime Analyzer | No | Yes |
| Advanced Viewer (SSD stats etc.) | No | Yes |
| Custom Printing Templates | No | Yes |
| Notifications | No | Yes |

The site says all versions of Plus are one-time purchases, offers a Lifetime Edition with "all future Plus updates" and a "coconutBattery 4 only" option limited to v4.x updates, and describes a trial that starts the app ten times in Plus mode, activated in the app settings. Prices are filled in at checkout and I could not read one from the page, so check it there. The page does not say which features remain without a purchase beyond that trial, so test the trial before you decide. The app is available only from coconut-flavour.com, not from an App Store.

## Which to trust for what

| Question | Use |
| --- | --- |
| Does this battery need service or a warranty claim | System Settings **Condition** and **Maximum Capacity** |
| How fast is it aging month to month | The same field, recorded on a schedule, or coconutBattery's history |
| What is the temperature or the raw capacity right now | coconutBattery or `ioreg` |
| What is my iPhone or iPad battery doing | coconutBattery, or the iPhone's own Battery Health screen |

Pick one source for trends and keep using it, because two sources with different definitions will not line up. If you are also deciding on charge limits, [do you still need AlDente now macOS has a charge limit](https://mole.fit/blog/aldente-vs-macos-charge-limit) covers that choice.

## Where Mole fits

[Mole](https://mole.fit/) reads the **Maximum Capacity** that `system_profiler` publishes before any figure it works out itself, and falls back to a ratio of raw capacities only when that is missing. **Status** shows it on the Battery tile as a health chip, with **Maximum capacity**, the cycle count and **Battery temperature** in the tile's hover text. When neither percentage is available, the chip shows the condition instead, such as **Service Recommended**. The Battery sensor card lists **Cycle Count** and **Full Charge Capacity** in mAh. Mole does not show design capacity or the manufacture date, and it keeps no saved battery-health history. For iPhones and iPads it reads only the charge level and charging state of a paired, trusted device, through the system's MobileDevice framework, and draws them as battery rings beside the Mac's own, with no health figure for them. Mole's rings for connected accessories are covered in [how to check AirPods battery on Mac](https://mole.fit/blog/how-to-check-airpods-battery-on-mac). If you later uninstall coconutBattery, [its tested-app guide](https://mole.fit/tested-apps/coconutbattery) lists what it leaves behind.

## FAQ

### Is coconutBattery accurate?

It reads battery data the Mac reports, and its percentage can differ from macOS because it is a different calculation. For service decisions Apple says to rely on the information macOS reports, and coconutBattery's raw capacities and history are useful for trends.

### Why does coconutBattery show a different health than System Settings?

System Settings shows **Maximum Capacity**, which macOS reports. coconutBattery shows **Battery Health**, which matches the ratio of **Full Charge Capacity** to **Design Capacity** in its own screenshot. On one MacBook those raw values divided to a few points below the 100% macOS reported.

### Is coconutBattery free?

Its site lists a comparison of coconutBattery and Plus, one-time purchase options and a trial of ten Plus-mode launches, and gives no price on the page. Check the trial in the app settings before buying.

### Can coconutBattery read an iPhone or iPad battery?

Yes, the site lists an iPhone/iPad battery diagnostic in both columns, and Plus adds reading over Wi-Fi without a USB cable and iPhone or iPad details in the menu bar.

### Does Mole show iPhone or iPad battery health?

No. Mole shows the charge level and charging state of a paired iPhone or iPad as a ring, and shows no health or capacity figure for it.

---

Canonical HTML page: https://mole.fit/blog/coconutbattery-vs-system-settings-mac
Blog index for agents: https://mole.fit/blog/llms.txt
Site index for agents: https://mole.fit/llms.txt
